Defame1297/holocron
0
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 14 Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 3 Wiki Activity

docs: mark simplification-audit findings 10, 12, 30 resolved

Browse Source 
Checkbox and strikethrough findings 10, 12, and 30, each pointing at
the commit that implemented it (edcc57c, 629320b). Record the decision
on findings 9 and 26 (delete docs/research and docs/notes): declined,
those docs are kept on purpose as context for work sourced from them.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01YR2CjVumUbEGWcMikcoXBD
This commit is contained in:
Defame1297
2026-09-12 18:38:40 +00:00
parent 629320b8fd
commit 198eafd790
1 changed files with 23 additions and 18 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

17
SIMPLIFICATION-AUDIT.md
View File

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ Counting convention: line counts are hand-edited `.apm/` source unless marked "i
## 1. The shape of the problem ## 1. The shape of the problem
| Measure | Value | | Measure | Value |
|---|---| | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------| -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Tracked files / lines | 820 / 102,000 | | Tracked files / lines | 820 / 102,000 |
| Lines in `plugins/` | 70,600 (69% of repo) | | Lines in `plugins/` | 70,600 (69% of repo) |
| Of which the 39 `SKILL.md` files a model actually loads | ~2,600 lines (under 4% of plugin lines) | | Of which the 39 `SKILL.md` files a model actually loads | ~2,600 lines (under 4% of plugin lines) |
@@ -88,13 +88,16 @@ The shared pattern: per-skill `README.md` files no model reads, a `docs/research
### 4.1 Cross-plugin (apply everywhere) ### 4.1 Cross-plugin (apply everywhere)
9. **Delete `docs/research/` from every plugin (~19,000 lines).** kyberforge's alone is 14,143 lines, 32% of the plugin, and about 8,900 of those are vendored third-party content (Anthropic `skill-creator` including a 1,325-line `viewer.html` and ten `.py` files, obra/superpowers, mattpocock). The rest is copied tool documentation. The gitea references explicitly say the research doc "has a known history of drifting from the deployed server". Every `apm.yml` uses `includes: auto`; whether the directory ships to consumers needs one check. Keep upstream URLs in one line per plugin README; git history keeps the rest. Check obra/superpowers licence if anything is retained. Goes together with finding 11: 32 `sources.md` files carry "Research doc" paths into these directories. Effort S. 9. [ ] **Delete `docs/research/` from every plugin (~19,000 lines).** kyberforge's alone is 14,143 lines, 32% of the plugin, and about 8,900 of those are vendored third-party content (Anthropic `skill-creator` including a 1,325-line `viewer.html` and ten `.py` files, obra/superpowers, mattpocock). The rest is copied tool documentation. The gitea references explicitly say the research doc "has a known history of drifting from the deployed server". Every `apm.yml` uses `includes: auto`; whether the directory ships to consumers needs one check. Keep upstream URLs in one line per plugin README; git history keeps the rest. Check obra/superpowers licence if anything is retained. Goes together with finding 11: 32 `sources.md` files carry "Research doc" paths into these directories. Effort S.
> **Decision (2026-09-12):** Keep. `docs/research/` is retained on purpose — it's read by agents doing work sourced from those docs. Not proceeding.
10. **Delete per-skill `README.md` and `references/README.md` (48 files, 1,574 lines).** They restate the SKILL.md in narrative form. The pre-commit config itself notes a skill README "is consumer-facing prose that no agent ever loads". Keep one plugin-level README with one line per skill. Requires dropping the README criterion in `skill-audit/references/file-structure.md` and the README step in `new-skill.sh`. Effort S. 10. [x] ~~**Delete per-skill `README.md` and `references/README.md` (48 files, 1,574 lines).** They restate the SKILL.md in narrative form. The pre-commit config itself notes a skill README "is consumer-facing prose that no agent ever loads". Keep one plugin-level README with one line per skill. Requires dropping the README criterion in `skill-audit/references/file-structure.md` and the README step in `new-skill.sh`. Effort S.~~
> **Done (2026-09-12):** see commit `edcc57c` on `docs/simplification-audit`. Deleted the 48 per-skill/reference READMEs plus 2 scaffold templates; dropped the README criterion from `skill-audit`'s `file-structure.md` and `finding-criteria.md` and the README-generation step from `new-skill.sh`; updated `new-skill.bats` to match. Plugin-root READMEs were kept, not part of this finding.
11. **Drop the provenance chain: `sources.md`, `source_keys` frontmatter, `validate-provenance.sh`.** 32 plugin and skill `sources.md` files (about 1,300 lines) plus 9 research indexes, 216 source files with `source_keys`, two copies of the validator (1,198 and 632 lines) with ten checks, and 125 bats tests exist to track which upstream informed which file. Git blame and a URL in the README do the same job. This is more code than the content it tracks. Effort M (touches skill-audit, both validator copies, two repo tests, and every skill's frontmatter). 11. **Drop the provenance chain: `sources.md`, `source_keys` frontmatter, `validate-provenance.sh`.** 32 plugin and skill `sources.md` files (about 1,300 lines) plus 9 research indexes, 216 source files with `source_keys`, two copies of the validator (1,198 and 632 lines) with ten checks, and 125 bats tests exist to track which upstream informed which file. Git blame and a URL in the README do the same job. This is more code than the content it tracks. Effort M (touches skill-audit, both validator copies, two repo tests, and every skill's frontmatter).
12. **Strip ADR and changelog narration from model-facing files.** `ADR-0020` is cited in 3 of 7 kyberforge SKILL.md files and 16 references; ADR-0023 is cited inline 21 times in the git plugin. Examples: "was the old house rule and ADR-0020 deleted it", "were removed per ADR-0015 once issue #90 landed", "this file previously recorded `list_issues` as having neither a `type` nor a `milestones` parameter". `skill-author/references/retrofit.md` (197 lines) is a one-time migration guide; it is loaded from `improve.md` and listed in `sources.md`, so remove those in the same change. These belong in git history or the ADR, not in context. Effort S. 12. [x] ~~**Strip ADR and changelog narration from model-facing files.** `ADR-0020` is cited in 3 of 7 kyberforge SKILL.md files and 16 references; ADR-0023 is cited inline 21 times in the git plugin. Examples: "was the old house rule and ADR-0020 deleted it", "were removed per ADR-0015 once issue #90 landed", "this file previously recorded `list_issues` as having neither a `type` nor a `milestones` parameter". `skill-author/references/retrofit.md` (197 lines) is a one-time migration guide; it is loaded from `improve.md` and listed in `sources.md`, so remove those in the same change. These belong in git history or the ADR, not in context. Effort S.~~
> **Done (2026-09-12):** see commit `edcc57c` on `docs/simplification-audit`. Historical narration stripped from kyberforge (ADR-0020) and git (ADR-0023) skill content; `retrofit.md` deleted along with its load-step and `sources.md` entries. Caught in review: some `ADR-0023` tags were not narration but the `check-rtk-prefix` hook's required opt-out marker for intentionally-bare git commands — those 12 were restored, not left stripped.
13. **State repeated boilerplate once or delete it.** A near-identical "Resolve owner and repo" block in 5 of 7 gitea skills; 404-masks-403 in 6 files; manual pagination in 7; main/master refusal in 9 git files; the "use the project's domain glossary, respect ADRs" paragraph in 5 bin skills. Three git skills define three different structured-result JSON shapes whose only consumer is `git-orchestrate` (finding 19). Effort S. 13. **State repeated boilerplate once or delete it.** A near-identical "Resolve owner and repo" block in 5 of 7 gitea skills; 404-masks-403 in 6 files; manual pagination in 7; main/master refusal in 9 git files; the "use the project's domain glossary, respect ADRs" paragraph in 5 bin skills. Three git skills define three different structured-result JSON shapes whose only consumer is `git-orchestrate` (finding 19). Effort S.
@@ -130,7 +133,8 @@ The shared pattern: per-skill `README.md` files no model reads, a `docs/research
## 5. Prose and docs (9,600 lines, 109,000 words outside plugins) ## 5. Prose and docs (9,600 lines, 109,000 words outside plugins)
26. **Move or delete `docs/research/` and `docs/notes/` (4,500 lines, 47% of prose words).** Six of eleven research files are linked only from each other; they are self-described session audit trails, agendas, and a "temporary build reference". `docs/notes/factory-research-gaps-conflicts.md` says "Status: Superseded"; `factory-integration-decisions.md` says "Complete" and its decisions already live in ADRs, yet `AGENTS.md` tells every session to read it. `archive/team-self-organisation-sprint-brief.md` (3,400 words) is unrelated to this repo. Archive or delete; drop the three `AGENTS.md` pointers. Moving `CONTROLS.md` to `docs/spec/` means updating its literal path in nine or more files including the deployed `governance.md`. Effort S. 26. [ ] **Move or delete `docs/research/` and `docs/notes/` (4,500 lines, 47% of prose words).** Six of eleven research files are linked only from each other; they are self-described session audit trails, agendas, and a "temporary build reference". `docs/notes/factory-research-gaps-conflicts.md` says "Status: Superseded"; `factory-integration-decisions.md` says "Complete" and its decisions already live in ADRs, yet `AGENTS.md` tells every session to read it. `archive/team-self-organisation-sprint-brief.md` (3,400 words) is unrelated to this repo. Archive or delete; drop the three `AGENTS.md` pointers. Moving `CONTROLS.md` to `docs/spec/` means updating its literal path in nine or more files including the deployed `governance.md`. Effort S.
> **Decision (2026-09-12):** Keep. Same reasoning as finding 9 — these docs are intentional context for sourced work. Not proceeding.
27. **Four governance documents say one thing.** `core/instructions/governance.md` (949 words, always-on), `docs/ai-constitution.md` (2,906), `docs/wiki/HUMANS.md` (1,413), `CONTROLS.md` (1,224), with near-identical preambles and, in three of the four, a "what this file does not govern" block pointing at the others. The constitution repeats one of its own principle lead sentences. Keep `governance.md` as the operative file, trimmed to about 50 lines (drop the classification table that repeats the bullets above it, the footer, the non-governance block). Dedupe the constitution by about 20%. Effort M. 27. **Four governance documents say one thing.** `core/instructions/governance.md` (949 words, always-on), `docs/ai-constitution.md` (2,906), `docs/wiki/HUMANS.md` (1,413), `CONTROLS.md` (1,224), with near-identical preambles and, in three of the four, a "what this file does not govern" block pointing at the others. The constitution repeats one of its own principle lead sentences. Keep `governance.md` as the operative file, trimmed to about 50 lines (drop the classification table that repeats the bullets above it, the footer, the non-governance block). Dedupe the constitution by about 20%. Effort M.
@@ -138,7 +142,8 @@ The shared pattern: per-skill `README.md` files no model reads, a `docs/research
29. **The same facts are stated in full three or four times.** "Edit `.apm/`, never the mirror": README (2 paragraphs), AGENTS.md (2 paragraphs), architecture.md (2 paragraphs plus the lost-README anecdote), ADR-0017. The apm.lock / SessionStart story: README (11 lines), AGENTS.md, ADR-0018, ADR-0019, gates.md. The offline `SKIP=` command and the three-stage install each appear three times. Rule: README has the how-to, AGENTS.md has one-line rules with links, architecture.md has mechanics. Effort S. 29. **The same facts are stated in full three or four times.** "Edit `.apm/`, never the mirror": README (2 paragraphs), AGENTS.md (2 paragraphs), architecture.md (2 paragraphs plus the lost-README anecdote), ADR-0017. The apm.lock / SessionStart story: README (11 lines), AGENTS.md, ADR-0018, ADR-0019, gates.md. The offline `SKIP=` command and the three-stage install each appear three times. Rule: README has the how-to, AGENTS.md has one-line rules with links, architecture.md has mechanics. Effort S.
30. **`LESSONS.md`: 41 entries, 2 graduated, about 12 stale.** Twelve entries from 2026-05-17 describe a write-skill / write-eval workflow whose skills no longer exist. One entry is open work labelled "Status: neither part landed". The longest eight are 200 to 550-word incident reports. Delete the stale entries, move open work to an issue, cap entries at about 60 words, target 100 lines. Effort S. 30. [x] ~~**`LESSONS.md`: 41 entries, 2 graduated, about 12 stale.** Twelve entries from 2026-05-17 describe a write-skill / write-eval workflow whose skills no longer exist. One entry is open work labelled "Status: neither part landed". The longest eight are 200 to 550-word incident reports. Delete the stale entries, move open work to an issue, cap entries at about 60 words, target 100 lines. Effort S.~~
> **Done (2026-09-12):** see commit `629320b` on `docs/simplification-audit`. 255→131 lines, 41→30 entries. Kept 3 of the same-dated entries (RLHF defaults, secrets-rule gap, HITL gap) — judged unrelated to the defunct write-skill/write-eval workflow and still applicable, so 10 deleted rather than 12. The "neither part landed" open-work entry (CONTEXT.md not `@import`ed at session start) was removed rather than filed as an issue — full text preserved in this session's transcript if wanted later.
31. **`CONTEXT.md`: 28 terms, most used only by gates.md, scripts, or tests rather than by skills;** two (Preload tax, Skill context contract) are never used outside `CONTEXT.md` and ADR-0020. The preload-tax entry quotes two dated numbers then says not to quote them. The example dialogue and flagged-ambiguities sections are grill residue. Cut to about 20 one-line terms. Effort S. 31. **`CONTEXT.md`: 28 terms, most used only by gates.md, scripts, or tests rather than by skills;** two (Preload tax, Skill context contract) are never used outside `CONTEXT.md` and ADR-0020. The preload-tax entry quotes two dated numbers then says not to quote them. The example dialogue and flagged-ambiguities sections are grill residue. Cut to about 20 one-line terms. Effort S.